I know Inception will have a little divided opinion. But it has a lot to do with whole experience of anticipating a movie for long time, going through every poster every article every trailer and then countless heated discussions after watching it. I never had such experience for any other movie.
Thanks for comment, Sam. BTW, Did you see There Will be Blood yet ??
I've seen 71 of these and damn keen to see quite a few of the others. Awesome list, some great choices. You've got City of God, Requiem for a Dream, Schindler's List, LOTR, Memento and Seven which are probably all in my top 10. Sad to see no Fight Club or La Haine... two of my very favoutites!
Well, I haven't seen La Haine yet. One of the countless movies in my To Watch list and I am sorry but not a big fan of Fight Club. Everything else you mention is simply brilliant, no way I could have left any of them out.
Thanks for your kind words Pete. Good to see you approve.
So many great films!!! So awesome to see Waltz with Bashir in there - so amazing. Lots I've seen, lots I haven't! I was debating whether I should have the Lord of the Rings trilogy listed as three separate films or just one on my own list (which is no where near completion!) but I think I'm going to have to do what you did with it :)
Thanks Ruth !! To tell you the truth, I CANNOT differentiate between three LOTR Films(so much that I have to think which one is 2nd and which is 3rd haha). Even when I see them, I always see them all at one time, 11 hours straight. It's crazy but I have done it at least 15 times. :)
And Do Your List !! take your time but do it. I will love to see it.
Thanks !! So you haven't seen 12 Angry Men ?? Let me just tell you that I don't know a person who doesn't love it. Not like it, LOVE it. If possible, please give it a chance. You will not regret it.
Thanks. I really have been meaning to see that one, as I've read several really good reviews of it recently. It also sounds like the type of film that I would legitimately LIKE, even if it was released today and wasn't on the must see list for classics reasons.
I still need to see about 23 of these films. Solid choices overall though! I wonder how long it would take me to comprise a list of my own? I think trying to organize the rankings would be the hardest part.
Well, according to your Letterboxd acc, I have seen like sixth of the films you have seen and it took me months to do this. I reckon it should take more time if you have more options to choose from. So now you calculate. :)
Thanks for the comment CS !! It goes without saying that I recommend every one of these 23.
Wow! I must say that it's a great assemblage of movies. It has inspired me to come up with a similar feature on my blog. Some of my all time favorite movies that I thought missed your list are Stalker, Solyaris, Once Upon a Time in America, El Aura, Ran, Dersu Uzala, and The Return (2003).
As far as the ones that I am yet to get my hands on, I have added them to my Bucket List. Thanks a lot, Shantanu for coming up with such a brilliant feature on your highly informative blog.
Well, we have already talked about Ran and Dersu Uzala. About others, I actually haven't seen them except Once Upon a Time(So, they have gone to my bucket list) and I did consider Once Upon a Time in the list initially but then it went off.
Are you talking about Russian movie, The Return? If yes, it is in my Netflix Queue. I will get to it soon.
A fellow Incendies lover! An extraordinary film that was. Overwhelming at times. I like your list, a great blend of art house, blockbuster and mainstream (not saying this in a bad way) but I do find your exclusion of Back to the Future scary.
Thanks Myerla. Incendies was brilliant, just knocked me out completely. And about Back to the Future, It turns out that I haven't seen them yet(Did I scare you even more now ??). 80s and Me, don't get along too well.
AWESOME list, my friend. Pulp Fiction is my second favorite movie of all time - cool to see that it ranks so high among our favorite films of all time. Seriously great picks here.
Thanks a lot !! Well, Pulp Fiction IS that awesome right ?? Which is number 1 BTW ?? Also, one more Random question, Is there a movie in this list you haven't seen(I obviously have an impression you have seen almost everything)? Don't count Indian movies off course. :)
Wow !! That's heavy stuff. I will watch Taxi Driver and Persona at least 5 times before I will say a word about them. Deer Hunter has some stunning performances in it, 2001 also way ahead of its side.
Mary and Max is an animation but if you cared about Waltz with Bashir and Persepolis, I think you will like this one as well. It's Adam Elliot, if you have seen Harvey Krumpet - very similar in feel. It's on Instant if you want to give it a go.
Wow, this is a very, very surprising list! But it seems very honest. I like that you dared include a lot of blockbusters and even romantic comedies or "chick-flicks" (hate the term) like Easy A and The Devil Wears Prada! Also not many Indian films - I was surprised to see Sarfarosh! Guess I'll have to re-watch it, I remember not really liking it. And as for your #1; absolutely unexpected. On a whole a very likable list to me.
Thanks Mette !! Well, there are many blockbusters yes but I doubt there will be many people who won't call them good films. At least I hope so. :) and I am not sure if I will call Devil wears Prada a Chick-flick.
About Indian movies, Yes. Only 6. Sometimes I do feel like I am being little too critical on them. I actually just went through your list. Indian movies in our lists are mutually exclusive. I will love to hear your opinion about 6 here like Sarfarosh.
I will actually love to hear more on what is so surprising about Inception and list as a whole as well. Thanks Again though !!
The Devil Wears Prada is not a real chick flick, that's true... but it has elements of the genre.
To your question(s): Well, there are just so many extremely different films... some that I've never heard of and some that are very known but I haven't seen in many favourites lists. I just really like your list, it shows that you're a multi-facettet (?) person.
Of the remaining 5 Indian films I've only seen Taare Zameen Par, which I did like a lot, but wouldn't re-watch I think. It was so long and at times a little boring. But Satya is one of the films I've been wanting to see for a long time. Plus I've just rented A Wednesday.
Wow !! That might just be the one of the best compliment I have had !! Thanks !!
As for Satya, if you can do without sub-titles, here you go. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H782gXat2WQ. It's a full movie.
Let me know what you think of A Wednesday. I am trying to put it as mildly as I can but I am interested to see a non-Indian reaction to it. Again, I am really sorry if it is offensive in any way.
Not at all! I'll watch it some time in the next few days. Also thanks for the Satya-link - sadly it doesn't work in Germany because of copyrights, but I'm sure I'll find another way to watch the movie. Be looking out for my A Wednesday post :)
Here's my list: http://filmactually.blogspot.com/p/my-top-50-films.html
Btw, I watched Inception for the 5th time yesterday and it still thrills me. I even caught on to some new things this time. I have no qualms with you putting it at #1, this movie is EVERYTHING! That last 3rd part of the movie is just transcendent.
Nice selection of films! Some interesting and many surprising choices too! An interesting aspect of a list like that is how it evolves when someone discovers new films through time.
I agree with you. I have seen so many Great movies after making this list that I know for a fact that whenever I will revise this list, it will change drastically. So much that it might even be better to start from scratch.
I have to say you've almost got a completely list here - a few films overlooked like maybe the jacket, sunshine, The Fountain, The Tree of Life, American Beauty just to mention a few. Saying that I doubt I could come up with so many good titles in such a large quantity. Fantastic job. I'm working my way through the few I've not yet seen :)
Thanks !! I am glad you like it. And after all, there can only be 100. Some are bound to sip through the cracks, though I have to say most of your choices are good as well.
Have seen both. The Shining gets better every time but it hasn't cracked top 100 yet. And for Spaghatti Westerns as well, I like them but not as much to be in this list. :)
I am a huge film lover and I am so happy I found some else who's favorite movie is Inception. I feel like most films fans ride it off with too much action and say it's "too modern." You just made my day!
Not a fan of Nolan- at all. Cannot see any of the love for TDK or Inception- especially over all the rest. That being said: Memento is a superb film. Great that you like it :D Love the rest of the list though. Adore a lot of these movies myself and you are clearly VERY well versed in cinema. Considering your picks for Bergman, ever tried a Tarkovsky movie? Well worth it :)
I've seen exactly 50 of these films.
ReplyDeleteSurprised by your #1 pick.
Some great stuff here,
I know Inception will have a little divided opinion. But it has a lot to do with whole experience of anticipating a movie for long time, going through every poster every article every trailer and then countless heated discussions after watching it. I never had such experience for any other movie.
DeleteThanks for comment, Sam. BTW, Did you see There Will be Blood yet ??
I've seen 71 of these and damn keen to see quite a few of the others. Awesome list, some great choices. You've got City of God, Requiem for a Dream, Schindler's List, LOTR, Memento and Seven which are probably all in my top 10. Sad to see no Fight Club or La Haine... two of my very favoutites!
ReplyDeleteWell, I haven't seen La Haine yet. One of the countless movies in my To Watch list and I am sorry but not a big fan of Fight Club. Everything else you mention is simply brilliant, no way I could have left any of them out.
DeleteThanks for your kind words Pete. Good to see you approve.
So many great films!!! So awesome to see Waltz with Bashir in there - so amazing. Lots I've seen, lots I haven't! I was debating whether I should have the Lord of the Rings trilogy listed as three separate films or just one on my own list (which is no where near completion!) but I think I'm going to have to do what you did with it :)
ReplyDeleteThanks Ruth !! To tell you the truth, I CANNOT differentiate between three LOTR Films(so much that I have to think which one is 2nd and which is 3rd haha). Even when I see them, I always see them all at one time, 11 hours straight. It's crazy but I have done it at least 15 times. :)
DeleteAnd Do Your List !! take your time but do it. I will love to see it.
A great list. I haven't seen as many of these as I should have, but did manage to catch your top 3!
ReplyDeleteThanks !! So you haven't seen 12 Angry Men ?? Let me just tell you that I don't know a person who doesn't love it. Not like it, LOVE it. If possible, please give it a chance. You will not regret it.
DeleteThanks. I really have been meaning to see that one, as I've read several really good reviews of it recently. It also sounds like the type of film that I would legitimately LIKE, even if it was released today and wasn't on the must see list for classics reasons.
DeleteI still need to see about 23 of these films. Solid choices overall though! I wonder how long it would take me to comprise a list of my own? I think trying to organize the rankings would be the hardest part.
ReplyDeleteWell, according to your Letterboxd acc, I have seen like sixth of the films you have seen and it took me months to do this. I reckon it should take more time if you have more options to choose from. So now you calculate. :)
DeleteThanks for the comment CS !! It goes without saying that I recommend every one of these 23.
Wow! I must say that it's a great assemblage of movies. It has inspired me to come up with a similar feature on my blog. Some of my all time favorite movies that I thought missed your list are Stalker, Solyaris, Once Upon a Time in America, El Aura, Ran, Dersu Uzala, and The Return (2003).
ReplyDeleteAs far as the ones that I am yet to get my hands on, I have added them to my Bucket List. Thanks a lot, Shantanu for coming up with such a brilliant feature on your highly informative blog.
Thanks Murtaza !! You are too kind.
ReplyDeleteWell, we have already talked about Ran and Dersu Uzala. About others, I actually haven't seen them except Once Upon a Time(So, they have gone to my bucket list) and I did consider Once Upon a Time in the list initially but then it went off.
Are you talking about Russian movie, The Return? If yes, it is in my Netflix Queue. I will get to it soon.
Well, the pleasure is all mine! Yes, the one directed by Andrei Zvyagintsev, who is widely regarded as the contemporary Tarkovsky.
DeleteA fellow Incendies lover! An extraordinary film that was. Overwhelming at times. I like your list, a great blend of art house, blockbuster and mainstream (not saying this in a bad way) but I do find your exclusion of Back to the Future scary.
ReplyDeleteThanks Myerla. Incendies was brilliant, just knocked me out completely. And about Back to the Future, It turns out that I haven't seen them yet(Did I scare you even more now ??). 80s and Me, don't get along too well.
DeleteAWESOME list, my friend. Pulp Fiction is my second favorite movie of all time - cool to see that it ranks so high among our favorite films of all time. Seriously great picks here.
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot !! Well, Pulp Fiction IS that awesome right ?? Which is number 1 BTW ?? Also, one more Random question, Is there a movie in this list you haven't seen(I obviously have an impression you have seen almost everything)? Don't count Indian movies off course. :)
ReplyDeleteHa, okay, my Top 5 of all time is:
ReplyDelete1. Taxi Driver
2. Pulp Fiction
3. Persona
4. The Deer Hunter
5. 2001: A Space Odyssey
And movies I haven't seen on this list (not counting Indian flicks)... just one, Mary & Max. It's good?
Wow !! That's heavy stuff. I will watch Taxi Driver and Persona at least 5 times before I will say a word about them. Deer Hunter has some stunning performances in it, 2001 also way ahead of its side.
DeleteMary and Max is an animation but if you cared about Waltz with Bashir and Persepolis, I think you will like this one as well. It's Adam Elliot, if you have seen Harvey Krumpet - very similar in feel. It's on Instant if you want to give it a go.
Good stuff, I think I'll do just that! That way I can say I've seen your Top 100. Now, about those Indian movies...
DeleteRight. Finding them might be little tricky. But for a start, A Wednesday is on Instant watch. Some of the others are on YouTube if you want them.
DeleteWow, this is a very, very surprising list! But it seems very honest. I like that you dared include a lot of blockbusters and even romantic comedies or "chick-flicks" (hate the term) like Easy A and The Devil Wears Prada!
ReplyDeleteAlso not many Indian films - I was surprised to see Sarfarosh! Guess I'll have to re-watch it, I remember not really liking it.
And as for your #1; absolutely unexpected. On a whole a very likable list to me.
Thanks Mette !! Well, there are many blockbusters yes but I doubt there will be many people who won't call them good films. At least I hope so. :) and I am not sure if I will call Devil wears Prada a Chick-flick.
DeleteAbout Indian movies, Yes. Only 6. Sometimes I do feel like I am being little too critical on them. I actually just went through your list. Indian movies in our lists are mutually exclusive. I will love to hear your opinion about 6 here like Sarfarosh.
I will actually love to hear more on what is so surprising about Inception and list as a whole as well. Thanks Again though !!
The Devil Wears Prada is not a real chick flick, that's true... but it has elements of the genre.
DeleteTo your question(s): Well, there are just so many extremely different films... some that I've never heard of and some that are very known but I haven't seen in many favourites lists. I just really like your list, it shows that you're a multi-facettet (?) person.
Of the remaining 5 Indian films I've only seen Taare Zameen Par, which I did like a lot, but wouldn't re-watch I think. It was so long and at times a little boring. But Satya is one of the films I've been wanting to see for a long time. Plus I've just rented A Wednesday.
Wow !! That might just be the one of the best compliment I have had !! Thanks !!
DeleteAs for Satya, if you can do without sub-titles, here you go. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H782gXat2WQ. It's a full movie.
Let me know what you think of A Wednesday. I am trying to put it as mildly as I can but I am interested to see a non-Indian reaction to it. Again, I am really sorry if it is offensive in any way.
Not at all! I'll watch it some time in the next few days. Also thanks for the Satya-link - sadly it doesn't work in Germany because of copyrights, but I'm sure I'll find another way to watch the movie.
DeleteBe looking out for my A Wednesday post :)
Hmm, nice list. I think we have pretty similar taste! I'm working through my own top 50 list and I think we will have a lot of similar films.
ReplyDeleteThanks !! I shall look forward to your list eagerly !!
DeleteHere's my list: http://filmactually.blogspot.com/p/my-top-50-films.html
DeleteBtw, I watched Inception for the 5th time yesterday and it still thrills me. I even caught on to some new things this time. I have no qualms with you putting it at #1, this movie is EVERYTHING! That last 3rd part of the movie is just transcendent.
Great ! I will have a look sometime today.
Delete@Inception: It sure does fella. That movie IS everything. :)
Nice selection of films! Some interesting and many surprising choices too! An interesting aspect of a list like that is how it evolves when someone discovers new films through time.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you. I have seen so many Great movies after making this list that I know for a fact that whenever I will revise this list, it will change drastically. So much that it might even be better to start from scratch.
DeleteThanks for stopping by !
I have to say you've almost got a completely list here - a few films overlooked like maybe the jacket, sunshine, The Fountain, The Tree of Life, American Beauty just to mention a few. Saying that I doubt I could come up with so many good titles in such a large quantity. Fantastic job. I'm working my way through the few I've not yet seen :)
ReplyDeleteThanks !! I am glad you like it. And after all, there can only be 100. Some are bound to sip through the cracks, though I have to say most of your choices are good as well.
Deletealso man on fire, leon, taxi driver, the pianist, the machinist
ReplyDeleteHi Shantanu,
ReplyDeleteHere is my latest Top 100... would love to hear your thoughts on it :-)
Oops... here's the link for the same:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.apotpourriofvestiges.com/2013/04/all-time-best-100-movies-editors-pick.html
Hi Shantanu,
ReplyDeleteI this you also need to check following movies -
1) The Shining(1980)
2) 3-Iron(2004)
Also you do not seem to be a Spaghetti Western fan :)
Have seen both. The Shining gets better every time but it hasn't cracked top 100 yet. And for Spaghatti Westerns as well, I like them but not as much to be in this list. :)
DeleteI am a huge film lover and I am so happy I found some else who's favorite movie is Inception. I feel like most films fans ride it off with too much action and say it's "too modern." You just made my day!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteAmen to this!
DeleteNot a fan of Nolan- at all. Cannot see any of the love for TDK or Inception- especially over all the rest. That being said: Memento is a superb film. Great that you like it :D Love the rest of the list though. Adore a lot of these movies myself and you are clearly VERY well versed in cinema. Considering your picks for Bergman, ever tried a Tarkovsky movie? Well worth it :)
ReplyDelete